The Pharisees have had such a bad
press that we think the first man in this story must be a hypocrite. He was
not. He really has done all the things he lists in his prayer. The tax
collector, on the other hand, is a public sinner. He collects taxes for the
hated Roman government of occupation. Much of it goes into his own pocket.
Unable, like the Pharisee, to point in his prayer to any semblance of a good
conduct record, he appeals simply to God’s mercy: “O God, be merciful to me, a sinner."
Here is what our Emeritus Pope
Benedict XVI says about these two men in his book, Jesus of Nazareth
[pp. 61f]:
"The Pharisee can boast considerable virtues; he tells God only about
himself, and he thinks that he is praising God in praising himself. The tax
collector, on the other hand, knows that he has sinned, he knows he cannot boast
before God, and he prays in full awareness of his debt to grace. [“Grace” is
the technical term for God’s freely given love, something we can never earn.]
... The real point is ... that there are two ways of relating to God and to
oneself. The Pharisee does not really look at God at all, but only at himself;
he does not need God, because he does everything right by himself. He has no
real relation to God, who is ultimately superfluous: what he does himself is
enough.
“The tax collector, by contrast, sees
himself in the light of God. He has looked toward God, and in the process his
eyes have been opened to see himself. So, he knows that he needs God and that
he lives by God’s goodness, which he can not force God to give him and which he
cannot procure for himself. He knows that he needs mercy and so he will learn
from God’s mercy to become merciful himself, and thereby to become like God.
... He will always need the gift of goodness, or forgiveness, but in receiving
it he will always learn to give the gift to others.”
Happy are we if those words describe
us: people who know we shall always need the gift of God’s goodness and
forgiveness; and if, in receiving these gifts we learn to pass them on to
others.