May 5th, 2019: Third Sunday of Easter, Year C. John
21:1-19
AIM: To instill hope by
showing the greatness of Peter=s vocation, despite his weakness.
AHave you caught anything?@ Jesus calls out from the shore at
dawn to his friends in their boat, weary from a night of unsuccessful fishing. What
he really said was: AYou haven=t caught anything, have you?@ Jesus was having fun with them. In
addition to the fun of surprising them by appearing at all, he was poking fun
at their lack of success in the one thing they were supposed to be good at:
catching fish. Not once in the gospels is there any record of Peter and his
friends catching a single fish without Jesus= help. Here that help consists in the
suggestion that they try again. As soon as they do, they feel the net heavy
with fish. One of those in the boat tells Peter: AIt is the Lord.@ It is the unnamed Adisciple whom Jesus loved,@ as he is called in this gospel
according to John. Peter and the others hurry ashore and find a charcoal fire
with fish on it, and bread. What a beautiful human touch that is. Knowing that they would be hungry after their
long night=s labor, Jesus has made breakfast for
them.
Did Peter recall another charcoal
fire, not at daybreak but at night, in the courtyard of the High Priest=s house at Jerusalem, where Peter stood warming himself?
We cannot know. It is clear, however, that he was soon remembering what he had done
at that other charcoal fire. Jesus= thrice repeated question, ADo you love me?@ reminded Peter all too vividly of how
he had done what Jesus had warned him, only hours before, that he would do C and what Peter had immediately
boasted he would never do. Three times Peter had denied that he even knew his
Master, even as Jesus was on trial for his life in a nearby room.
APeter was distressed,@ we heard in the gospel, because
Jesus asked his question a third time. Of course he was distressed! The memory
of that three-fold denial was painful. Peter=s thrice repeated assurance of love
is his rehabilitation. In response to each pledge of love, Jesus assigns Peter
responsibility: to feed Jesus= sheep. It is noteworthy, however, that the flock entrusted
to Peter=s care remains the Lord=s: Amy lambs ... my sheep.@ Jesus himself is Athe chief shepherd,@ as we read in the First Letter of
Peter (5:4).
Why did Jesus give this
responsibility to Peter, of all people? It cannot have been because Peter loved
Jesus most. There was another present at that lakeside breakfast who clearly
loved Jesus more; who never deserted him; who, alone of all Jesus= male disciples, stood by his cross
as he died. If love were the basis for the office of chief shepherd after the
Lord himself, the office would have gone to Athe disciple whom Jesus loved.@
Jesus gave the office of leader to
the friend whose love was imperfect; whose impetuosity and weakness made
the name Jesus gave him C Peter, the rock C as ironic as calling a 350-pound
heavyweight ATiny.@ As long as Peter thought that he was
strong; as long as he could boast that though all others might desert Jesus, he
would remain faithful, Peter was not ready for leadership. For that Peter had
to experience his weakness. He had to become convinced that without a power
greater than his own, he could do nothing.
Part of that process was discovering
that he could not even catch a fish without Jesus= help. Peter had to learn his
weakness through the humiliation of failure: failure at fishing; failure in the
face of Jesus= clear warning, failure despite his
boast that he, at least, would never fail. And it was to this weak man, this
boaster, that Jesus entrusted the care of his church.
There is a famous painting which some
of you have surely seen. It shows a man being crucified upside down. It is
Peter. Here is the story behind the picture. At the end of his life, Peter was
in Rome, where
Christians were persecuted because they refused to pledge allegiance to the
Roman emperor. Peter was arrested and condemned to death by crucifixion.
Shortly before the date fixed for his
death Peter managed to escape. As he walked out of the city, under cover of
darkness, he encountered a familiar figure walking toward him. It was Jesus.
“Where are you going, Lord?” Peter asked.
“I’m going to Rome, Peter, to be crucified again, for you.”
Mortified and ashamed, Peter turned around
and went back into the city. When they came to crucify him the next morning,
Peter told the executioner that he was not worthy to die as his Lord had died. The
executioner obliged him by nailing him to the cross upside down. Outside Rome today there is
church with a name that recalls this story. It is the Church of Quo Vadis:
two Latin words which mean “Where are you going?”
Is that story history – or legend?
There is no need to answer that question. The story tells us that to the end Peter
remained weak – but that he truly loved the Lord despite this weakness.
Is there someone in this church today
who feels weak? You have made so many good resolutions. Some you have kept.
Many you have not. You have high ideals. Yet time and again you have compromised.
You had so many dreams, hopes, plans. How many have you achieved? You wanted so
much. You have settled for so little. If that is your story, you have a
friend in heaven. His name is Simon Peter.
If Peter=s story is yours C boasting followed by humiliating
failure; impetuosity and then indecisiveness; pledges of loyalty no matter
what, and then swift betrayal C if you see any of that in your life, or even all of that, then
Jesus has a task for you. He is saying to you, as he said to Peter: AFollow me.@
If, like Peter, you have discovered
that you are weak, that command is reassuring. Jesus does not ask you to be
strong, for he knows your weakness. He does not ask you to be a pioneer or a
leader. He knows that is too hard: that you would soon lose your way C or at least your nerve. He asks one
thing alone. He asks you to follow him.
Speaking a few years ago in Rome
about Peter, Pope Benedict XVI, now retired, said that we often think of Peter
as weak before the resurrection, but afterwards B especially after the gift of the
Holy Spirit at Pentecost B as strong. The reality, the Pope said, is more complex. Despite
the strengthening gift of the Holy Spirit, first given to Peter and the other
disciples of Jesus at Pentecost, Peter retained to the end of his life something
of his old weakness, the Pope said. Though remaining faithful to the Lord who
had called him was sometimes easy for Peter, there were also times when it was horribly
difficult.
For us too following Jesus Christ is
not always easy, for he leads often through difficult ways. If you know your
weakness, however, you have an advantage over those who still think they are
strong. Then you will trust, as you try to follow your Master and Lord, not in
any strength of your own, but only and always in the strength of Jesus Christ. His
strength is always reliable; and it is always available. We have only to ask
Jesus, and his strength there.